The Top 50 Mets of All Time: #33 Tommie Agee
In 1967, the Mets went 61-101, clearing the century mark in losses for the fifth time in six seasons (the outlier, 1966, saw them lose only 95 games). Looking to shore up their defense and get a bit younger in the process, on December 15, 1967, the Mets completed a long-discussed trade that sent left-fielder Tommy Davis, pitcher Jack Fisher, and two others to the Chicago White Sox in exchange for utility infielder -- and Long Island native -- Al Weis and young centerfielder Tommie Agee. Agee had won the rookie of the year and finished eighth in MVP voting in 1966, but a tough sophomore campaign enabled the Mets to pry him loose.
| Year | Age | PA | XBH | BB | AVG | OBP | SLG | EQA | WARP3 | VORP |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1968 | 25 | 391 | 20 | 15 | .217 | .255 | .307 | .224 | 1.0 | -10.0 |
| 1969 | 26 | 635 | 53 | 59 | .271 | .342 | .464 | .293 | 8.4 | 27.2 |
| 1970 | 27 | 696 | 61 | 55 | .286 | .344 | .469 | .285 | 8.5 | 32.1 |
| 1971 | 28 | 482 | 33 | 50 | .285 | .362 | .428 | .307 | 6.5 | 26.8 |
| 1972 | 29 | 483 | 26 | 53 | .227 | .317 | .374 | .263 | 3.4 | 3.1 |
Agee's Met career got off to a suboptimal start. He was nailed in the back of the head by a Bob Gibson fastball in his very first spring training plate appearance, returning six days later, none the worse for wear. Once the regular season finally rolled around, Agee hit just .109/.144/.152 over his first 28 games, spanning 98 plate appearances. He wasn't a whole lot better the rest of the way, hitting .254/.292/.359 in his last 104 games to close the season with a putrid .217/.255/.307 line.

The end result was cringe-worthy, but Agee did pick his game up as the season wore on. He was hitting just .177/.220/.264 after the Mets drubbed the Giants 8-0 at Shea, but over his final 85 plate appearances -- 29 games' worth -- he hit .363/.386/.463, enough of a surge for manager Gil Hodges to all-but-guarantee Agee's place in centerfield for the following season.
Hoping to continue his hot swinging, Agee spent part of the winter with the Mets' instructional league team in St. Petersburg, Florida. It worked. Well, sort of. Agee collected five hits -- two of them homeruns -- and knocked in six runs in the first three games of the 1969 season, but picked up just three hits in his next 28 at-bats as his batting average dropped to .195 and he quickly found himself riding the bench in Hodges's doghouse.
Agee appeared sporadically over the subsequent three weeks, picking up just ten plate appearances over the Mets' next 17 games. Perhaps illustrating the fickle nature of batting average and small sample sizes, Agee raised his average to .265 in those ten times to the plate. He returned to the lineup for good on May 10 against the Astros, and smacked three homeruns in a double-header the next day. He would appear in 131 of the team's final 135 games -- making 129 starts along the way -- and finished with a .271/.342/.464 line, trailing only teammate and fellow Alabamian Cleon Jones for the team lead in OPS among starters.
Thanks in no small part to Agee's terrific season, the Mets shocked the baseball world by capturing the NL East title and stormed into the playoffs to face the Braves in the NLCS. Agee was brilliant against Atlanta, hitting .357/.438/.857 with two homeruns and four RsBI as the Mets swept in three games to move on to the franchise's first World Series appearance. Agee didn't fare quite so well against Baltimore in the Fall Classic, hitting just .167/.250/.333 in the five-game series, but his efforts in the Series' third game made up for any shortcomings otherwise.
With the Series tied at a game apiece and Shea hosting its first World Series game, Agee led off the bottom of the first with a clout to centerfield that put the Mets ahead, 1-0. The rest of his Game 3 heorics came with the glove, with which he made two incredible catches, including this one that robbed Paul Blair of an extra-base hit with the bases loaded and two outs in the top of the seventh. The Mets went on to win that game -- and the next two -- to capture their first World Series title against the heavily-favored Orioles (here is a photo montage the New York Times ran on 8/15/1969).

Fresh off his World Series celebration, Agee finished sixth in the NL MVP voting and was awarded a $40,000 contract for 1970. Continuing a pattern he established in his first two seasons with the Mets, Agee got off to a slow start again, hitting just .227/.310/.333 after the team's first 20 games and his first 84 plate appearances. Also like his first two seasons, Agee just took a little while to get going, as he hit .294/.349/.487 over his final 135 games. He also walloped eleven homeruns in June, setting a club mark for longballs in a month, had a 19-game hitting streak at one point, and won a game in tenth inning on a walk-off steal of home. He also picked up his second Gold Glove award for his play in centerfield. The Mets were tied for first place as late as September 14, but lost eight of their last eleven games to finish at 83-79, in third place in the NL East and six games behind the first-place Pirates.
Agee actually got off to a solid start in 1971, but was derailed by a right knee injury that cost him 20 games in June. He hit .287/.373/.439 for the 62 games that followed his return, but his season was halted again on September 4 when he "had 70 cubic centimeters of blood drained from his right knee" (New York Times, 9/5/1971). He missed fifteen more games recuperating, and the Mets finished the season tied for third, this time fourteen games in back of the Pirates.
Agee was reportedly healthy after an offseason of rest and light exercise, and the Mets signed him for the 1972 season for around $55,000, the same figure he earned in 1971. Agee's performance belied his assertion, as he struggled with the bat for much of the season. He missed a week with a groin strain at the beginning of July, came back for two games, then suffered a strained intercostal and missed the next three weeks. Agee muddled along -- much like the Mets -- for the remainder of the season, and finished with a disappointing .227/.317/.374 line.
Weary of Agee's growing list of injuries, the Mets dealt him to the Astros that offseason for Rich Chiles and Buddy Harris, who went on to do little and nothing for the Mets, respectively. Agee hit a collective .222/.281/.398 with the Astros and Cardinals in 1973, but by that time injuries had sapped almost all of the speed and power from his once-athletic body. He was cut by the Dodgers during spring training of 1974 and that was it for Agee, who, at just 30 years old, was officially out of baseball.
Tommie Agee went on to sell title insurance after his playing career ended, and he died following a heart attack on January 22, 2001 at the age of 58.
Though it took him some time to get rolling, Tommie Agee turned in three excellent seasons for the Mets from 1969 thru 1971. He was terrific in the 1969 NLCS and owned Game 3 of the World Series, his miraculous diving catch in the latter having left an indelible imprint on a generation of Mets fans. The rigors of the game wore him down far too soon, and though his life was cut tragically short, the images and vivid memories of his time spent in Queens live on.
0 recs |
13 comments
|
Comments
I love these
and thanks for saying “intercostal” instead of “rib muscle”
by HotChipWillBreakYourLegs on Nov 18, 2008 9:01 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
The only problem is...
by the time you get to Tom Seaver sometime in February 2012, the order will have to be revised because David Wright will have to be bumped up and Reyes and Santana and Beltran will likely belong on the list.
by JoshNY on Nov 18, 2008 10:37 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Not a big deal
The list has already changed since I started. If/when it’s ever finished I’ll probably just post yearly addenda.
by Eric Simon on Nov 18, 2008 10:47 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
I understand if you
would rather not reveal any info about subsequent lists, but would it be fair to say that Wright at 25 is already one of the 5 best position players in team history. He is second in career OPS, third in OPS+ and the counting stats are starting to add up (ie, top 10 in HRs, doubles, total bases).
"Since we became accelerated readers, we never leave the house." - Los Campesinos
by Shomov on Nov 18, 2008 11:57 AM EST up reply actions 0 recs
If not top five
then certainly top six. He should be firmly within the top three by the end of 2009.
by Eric Simon on Nov 18, 2008 12:16 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Some other stuff about Agee
1. Bing Devine fought long and hard to work out that trade for Agee. Unfortunately, he wasn’t able to complete it after working out all the details due to his resignation. Devine, a fantastic executive, quit to return to St. Louis, in part because he wanted to return and in part because he was unhappy in New York. The board of directors forced him to acquire Gil Hodges as manager, paying a pitching prospect and $100,000. Devine much preferred to grab Harry Walker or scouting director Whitey Herzog. It was a strange situation that ended with Devine being replaced by Johnny Murphy. According to Devine, he told Murphy he was free to make the trade for Agee or not.
2. What made the whole situation a little ironic is how well Hodges managed Agee. Agee had tremendous difficulty staying focused on the field; he would often let various doubts occupy his mind affecting his performance at the plate. Hodges, however, did what he could to alleviate Agee’s stress. Agee would spend hours in Hodges’s office dumping everything out. This was certainly an interruption for Hodges who had a whole team to manage, but both he and the rest of the team realized this was just something Tommie had to do. After Hodges died, Agee had lost both a friend and a confidant. He really wasn’t quite the same player and started to put on weight, which affected both his performance and durability.
3. For a guy who is remembered for making two outstanding catches, his defense in center was a little underrated, doubtless because of the presence of three NL contemporaries: Curt Flood, Willie Davis, and Willie Mays. But he was good enough in center to force the White Sox to put Ken Berry in right, a guy who’d later win and deserve two Gold Gloves in center.
4. An example of the Kirby Puckett body. Agee was always short and stocky despite being extremely fast and strong in his youth. So fast and strong, the Indians signed him to a $65,000 contract before the 1961 season despite his body type. (Agee’s performance was up-and-down in the minors, so the Indians shipped him and Tommy John off to the White Sox in a three-team trade that brought them Camilo Carreon—Mark’s father—and Rocky Colavito, who had one good season left. Not a good trade.)
by Alex Nelson on Nov 18, 2008 10:39 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Very interesting
Thank you for that addition.
"I just want to thank you for being such a goddam prince, that's all." - Holden Caulfield
by Prince on Nov 18, 2008 5:10 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
“The Mets were tied for first place as late as September 14, but lost eight of their last eleven games to finish at 83-79, in third place in the NL East and six games behind the first-place Pirates.”
Sounds familiar…
by cjmulrain on Nov 18, 2008 11:11 AM EST reply actions 0 recs
Number 37
I hope somebody has bought the number ‘37’ in concrete in the upper deck. Am amazing feat to hit a HR up there.
I’m too young to have seen Agee play, but my grandfather raved about his talent. Too bad he was came and went so quickly.
by whynot on Nov 18, 2008 12:52 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
From what I heard
That wasn’t going to be possible. I believe the problem was removing it without it crumbling to pieces.
by Alex Nelson on Nov 18, 2008 1:18 PM EST up reply actions 0 recs
Agee was a really nice guy
when I met him before a game in the Mets’ picnic area a few years back. He signed autographs for everyone and chatted for awhile. He died just a couple years later, sad stuff.
by James Kannengieser on Nov 18, 2008 4:52 PM EST reply actions 0 recs
Thank you, Eric.
This is exactly why I enjoy this series so much. It’s nice knowing that Bobby Bo wasn’t a complete failure, or that Bobby Jones really was a pretty decent pitcher, but the best of these so far have been about the guys I’m too young to have seen, like Milner, Lockwood, Henderson, and now Agee. I never realized that injuries cut his career short so young. Kind of surprising to discover I knew next to nothing about a player who contributed so much to the 1969 World Series title.
by BobbyV_Incognito on Nov 18, 2008 8:32 PM EST reply actions 0 recs






















