It's Not Worth Losing If You Can't Lose Big

I promised myself I wouldn't write another column belaboring the fact that the Mets' bullpen has completely fallen apart. I'll try to keep things brief, because I don't want to reiterate what we already know and, quite honestly, I'd rather think about kittens and butterflies and other things that give me decidedly less agita.
The Mets' bullpen ERA is up to 4.22, which is the fourth-worst in the National League and just a shade ahead of the Rockies, who play in the second-best hitter's park in baseball. Whatever lousy things you want to say about Billy Wagner, if it wasn't obvious before that he was the Mets' best reliever then it should be crystal clear now. I'm not going to confuse causation with coincidence here: I don't necessarily believe that the Mets' relief pitching has gone in the crapper simply because Wagner got hurt and everyone's job got pushed up a rung. I think the timing of the complete and utter meltdown is mysterious and unfortunate.
Aaron Heilman, I guess, has been especially bad. He has three losses and two blown saves in August alone, and though I've always considered myself a fan and a supporter, there really isn't much to cheer about at this point. He picked up a couple of saves in the Marlins series and a win in the Padres series, but otherwise has been dreadful for most of the season (though he had a nice stretch in the middle months there). He somehow has seven relief losses this season, and though wins and losses can often be misleading when used to judge starting pitchers, losses at least do give a pretty good indication of how a particular relief pitcher has fared. I'd still prefer to look at things like strikeout, walk and homerun rates, but Heilman has taken a pounding this year and all of those losses are just an extension of same.
After a week like this I just want to write the Mets off and shift into offseason/football mode. But I can't. I can't because I know they'll come out and win a bunch of games and be right back in the thick of things. I can't, because regardless of how bad the Mets look at times, they're not really terrible, and whatever their faults, they remain competitive in the NL East because the Phillies and Marlins suck just as much as they do. It's a frustrating cat-and-mouse game: the Mets play god awful baseball in an effort to push themselves out of the race and, perhaps, collect some tasty draft picks, but neither the Phillies nor the Marlins have been able to make any hay on their own, sputtering in neutral while the Mets alternate decent and crappy play.
And with all of this as the backdrop, the tired baseball platitudes become even more tired and even more platitudinal. I'd love to say that this next week will be huge for the Mets, but it probably won't be. The Mets could go 7-0 or 0-7 and probably not swap more than a couple of games in the standings. (side note: even as I write this, after having witnessed yet another horrific bullpen collapse at Shea -- perhaps the worst of the season to date -- the Phillies are losing 7-1 to the Dodgers and the Mets will probably end the day the same two games back that they started it). I so desperately want to throw in the towel but the rest of the NL East won't oblige.
And so I'll end with a humble plea to the Mets: if you're going to ultimately crap the bed, do it now, and do it right. I don't want another season that goes down to the wire only to end in despair and whatever the baseball equivalent of explosive diarrhea is. My psyche can't afford another last-day implosion, another horrible collapse, another close-but-no-cigar finish. Honestly, I'd rather you just lose every game for the next two weeks than lose out in September's waning days again. Don't get me wrong: I'd rather you make the playoffs than not, but if it's going to be not, save us the drama and just go out like dogs.
0 recs |
8 comments
Comments
I know this hurts
Eric I gotta respectfully disagree somewhat with what you’re saying here. Believe it or not (if you look at my curses per post), the Mets are about the one place in life where I try to teem with optimism through the most dour and dreadful moments. I curse, I jeer, I curse some more but, dang it, I still sit here and believe they can right the ship and pull things out.
That said, it would hurt but I’d rather see the team take things down to the last day and lose (again) than just crap their pants right now. I can’t sit through a meaningless month of baseball, and everyone from us all the way up to the front office has to know that this team needs significant re-modeling in the offseason, no matter how this season ends. But, c’mon, this is the one sport season that really matters during the year and if the Mets have even half a shout at getting to the playoffs, as bad as things have looked during the year, I’d prefer they took it even if it means losing once again on the last day. It’s not like last year where the lad are coming from ahead to blow it all during the last two weeks. That was painful in no uncertain terms.
Getting to the playoffs this year, however, would be one hell of a cosmic joke, all things considered. If they can drag this sorry carcass across the finish line and keep playing, wonderful. If they can make it to the last day but not make it, it still can’t sting as much as last year, not with the way things have been going day after day and relief pitcher after relief pitcher of late. I say play on and maybe break my heart again. I’m a dang Mets fan; I can take it.
'Catsmeat!' he cried. 'I see it all. It was that chump, Catsmeat.'
by Catsmeat Potter-Pirbright on Aug 12, 2008 11:56 AM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I hear ya
And, to tell the truth, I waffle between these two views practically on a daily basis. I wake up and I’m Joey Optimism. I know the bullpen struggles are probably blip-ish, and that they couldn’t possibly pitch so poorly for the rest of the way. The offense has come around somewhat: Wright is swinging a hot bat and Beltran has looked better of late. Jose Reyes is still one of the most valuable offensive players in the game, and Carlos Delgado, defying all logic, seems to have resurrected his career. The starting pitching is in pretty good shape, and despite a couple of rough outings I still think Pelfrey is on the road to super-stud-dom.
And then the Mets go out and play a game like last night’s and BLAARGGGGGGHHHHHHHHH. The switch flips and I’m in full-blown tear-it-up mode. It really all depends on when you get me. Right now I feel okay. When I wrote the above post at 11pm last night, not so much.
by Eric Simon on Aug 12, 2008 12:09 PM EDT up reply actions 0 recs
Oh, you know you love it...
We piss and moan. We sleep on it. We come back. It’s what we do. The 2008 Mets are like that girlfriend we can’t go more than two days without fighting. When it’s good it’s miraculous good. We say to ourselves, “we can’t go on like this.” And yet here we are.
"Those who fear disorder more than injustice inevitably produce more of both." -- Rev. William Coffin
by dcrockett17 on Aug 12, 2008 2:10 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
whether you like it or not
the Mets will be in this until the end. They are no way near as desperate as the Phillies were in mid-September and we all know what happened then. That being said, I say let the kids play out the string. Murphy should play every day and Evans should get more playing time. I think Tatis is bound to come back to earth. If FMart is healthy bring him up too and let him play frequently. As for the pitching let Kunz close for goodness sakes. Don’t worry about hurting his confidence and don’t condemn him for giving up one lousy home run. Manual often has his head up his ass just like Willie when it comes to playing the youngsters. When Billy comes back, give Kunz some important 8th- inning work. Niese should be brought up immediately and Maine should be put in the bullpen. As he did last year, Maine is showing that he is not a durable pitcher and probably can’t pitch 200 innings. I have a similar concern for Pelfrey, but he should keep on starting and we can hope for the best. I despise the pampering of these pitchers, but that’s the way it is. Funny you should say that Beltran is better lately ( I don’t really see it) when you would never admit when he wasn’t playing well to begin with. Delgado will become human again, but Wright will have to pick up the slack. I just don’t have confidence Beltran is going to get it done this year. Let Heilman mop up. Give Feliciano work against lefty swingers-same with Show. Muniz should be sent to the minors. Youth is wasted on Joe Smith who can’t seem to stay effective the whole year. I would trade him at the end of the year. Anyway, I don’t think offense is the real problem here. It’s the bullpen, bullpen, bullpen.
Save America. Impeach Bush
by elifriedman on Aug 12, 2008 2:38 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I'm onboard w/most of what you say Eric.
Forgive me for looking too far in the distant future (called October) but I honestly don’t want to see the METS get their hopes and our hopes up by pee-peeing their way to the playoffs w/the team playing the way they are and just getting in because the Phillies and Marlins suck.
I don’t want to see them blow 3 games in a row in the 1st round of the playoffs during the last inning(s) by a lowly team from the NL West or by the NL Central and NL Central wild card teams (most likely CUBS and BREWERS respectively).
I can see it now. Everyone totally stoked about the METS making the playoffs yet, everyone (players included) knowing in the back of their mind that come the 7th, 8th and 9th inning things may just blow up in their face.
Almost everyday of watching the METS this year is like facing the entire month of September last year.
"MY SERVICES ARE PRO BONO."
by LOUtheMETandNATSfan on Aug 12, 2008 3:25 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
I hate this bullpen
the real hard truth here is that the rest of the team has for the most part done its job despite the injuries. The offense has been fairly consistent since Willie got canned and while they still don’t hit in the clutch, it has not really hurt them in many games and they have scored plenty of runs. The starting pitching I think has been better than expected. The defense hasn’t been so great at times mostly Wright, Reyes and recently Endy Chavez. But they are still a solid defensive team. But this bullpen is a nightmare, maybe one of the worst ever for a team with a winning record. 19 blown saves and that ERA and those walks!! Thats what kills me, the walks to awful hitters late in games. If the bullpen were even average, we would have a six or seven game lead right now.
by Endys Game on Aug 12, 2008 4:26 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs
What makes this more frustrating
Is the lack of action by the front office to try to improve the team. I’m not advocating making a stupid move just to make a move, but it seems like other teams are acquiring useful to very good players without having to give up much. Dunn for a risky prospect and players to be named, P. Byrd for cash or PTBN, even the Nady-Marte trade was seen as a boarder line steal. How is it that all these other teams can make moves without giving up top prospects and yet the Mets can’t even find a scrap heap reliever? At this point I would take Washburn and his contract for next year if it frees up a starter (maybe Maine) to move to the bullpen. This team is not good enough to win, but they are not bad enough to lose and nothing is being done to change that. It’s going to be more of the same gut-wrenching inconsistency we have seen since last June.
Yes, they have lots of holes and one move won’t turn them into a contender. But, one move may be good enough to move them ahead of the Phillies and get them into the playoffs. Once they are there anything can happen.
by Reg Dunlop on Aug 12, 2008 7:00 PM EDT reply actions 0 recs



















