John Holdzkom, SP, Mets Minor League Scouting Report
I had the chance to see Holdzkom play over the weekend. Hopefully you all will like the report. I played baseball through college and did a little scouting afterwards for a few colleges and a defunct showcase company.
Scouting the Sally - John Holdzkom, P, NYM
John Holdzkom (7 IP, 2 H, 3 BB, 9 K) - Drafted in the 4th round by the New York Mets in the 2006 draft out of the Salt Lake Community College. He was previously drafted in the 15th round of the 2005 draft by the Seattle Mariners out of high school, but did not sign. A huge mound presence at 6'7", 225 lbs., I didn't quite know what to expect from him with a 6.92 ERA entering the evening. However, after his success in shutting down Rome's big three, I was left with no choice but to be impressed by the 20-year old's performance. Here are a few observations I came away from the game with;
- Mechanics could be a little tighter; Arms and legs seemed to be flying everywhere in his motion
- Limited athleticism?
- 1st inning - 86-91 fastball, topped out at 92 MPH
- In the middle innings, his fastball topped out at 95 with a handful of 94 MPH readings
- Fastball looked overpowering at times
- Consistently 88-91 in the 7th inning
- Began leaving fastballs up from the 5th on
- With 9 K, 3 BB, and other multi-pitch at bats, he had a pretty high pitch count
- With increased velocity came less control
- Less control from the stretch; Problems staying tall on his follow through
- Mid to high 80's cutter? Either that, or his FB velocity would differ greatly from pitch to pitch during particular at bats.
- Low to mid 80's change with good arm action; Unable to locate well
- May have snuck in a slider or two?
- Fought out of 1st and 2nd, 0 out jam by striking out Rome's #2 hitter and then getting Jason Heyward to ground into a 6-4-3
- Of the 2 hits allowed, 1 was a bunt hit
- One hard hit ball by Rome; 1st pitch L8 for a single by Heyward
Holdzkom's size and fastball are major league material to me. His size likely means a slower developmental curve than smaller pitchers because of problems repeating his mechanics as evidenced by 57 BB in 86 2/3 IP. I question whether a number of his strikeouts are a product of being able to blow it by lesser hitters. He will have trouble moving up without refining his breaking pitches and developing at least a serviceable 2nd offering. In my opinion, his change looked as if it had some potential with his arm action. He was wild with it, but I'd rather see balls in the dirt than changeups left belt high.
At this point, I can see him as possibly a power reliever, but not much else unless he can add to his repertoire. His getting Heyward to ground into a 6-4-3 double play in a scoreless ball game showed more guts than an ERA close to seven would indicate.
3 recs |
4 comments
Comments
Rec'd
Thanks! I love seeing content like this. Really nice scouting report.
by Eric Simon on
Aug 27, 2008 12:12 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
nice piece
I can’t even find anything much on Sickels’s site about this guy, all the “Holdzkom” hits are for his brother (I assume) Lincoln. Maybe predicting a major-league future for him at this point is a little premature, but I think you’re right that he could end up in the middle to back of somebody’s MLB bullpen in three or four years just based on the fastball.
by anonymous on
Aug 27, 2008 12:45 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Poor control from the stretch?
Isn’t this a significant issue for a would-be reliever, given that they pitch almost exclusively from the stretch? Sounds like he needs a lot of help with mechanics.
by madisonmetsfan on
Aug 28, 2008 12:30 PM EDT
reply
actions
0 recs
Response
You are absolutely correct. However, people tend to think that pitchers and hitters develop at the same rate when top hitters are usually in MLB by around 22 and pitchers at 24. Considering that Holdzkom was a 4th round pick and not a top pitcher, he could still spend another 5-6 years in the minor leagues and have a fine career as a reliever. He still has a sum total of just over 120 IP of minor league experience and a couple of more 120-150 IP seasons will give us a much better idea.
I also think that his spending 2+ years at rookie level goes to show his being a little behind the curve athletically as it pertains to making adjustments due to his size.
Mike Newman
baseballhandyman.blogspot.com
by Baseball Handyman on
Aug 29, 2008 2:50 PM EDT
up
reply
actions
0 recs











