(In the sprit of James’ post, Take Me Back to April.) 
Between Wright’s power outage and all the injuries, it’s been a really disappointing and frankly odd season.  Here’s a list of things I would have put money against at the start of the season: (apologies for bullet points)

•  The Mets would throw two complete game shut outs and they would be pitched by Nelson Figueroa and Pat Misch.
•  Tim Redding would have the third most strikeouts on the pitching staff (76.)
•  The owner of the third highest WAR for pitchers would be Livan Hernandez despite being released after 23 starts.
•  Daniel Murphy Blue Collar Blasts would lead the team. (12)
•  Fernando Nieve would lead the team in BA. (333 in 9 ABs)
•  David Wright would lead our team in SBs. (27)
•  Angel Pagan would have a higher ISO then Wright, Beltran or Sheff.
•  Small sample size issues of course, but our top three BB% owners would be Felicano, Andy Green, and Emil Brown.
•  Andy Green and Emil Brown would be on the team.
•  Fernando Tatis would have the 5th highest positional WAR on the team. (1.3)
•  Daniel Murphy would lead the team in UZR.  (4.2 at 1st)

Speaking of predictions:
I wanted to pat myself on the back for my best prediction of the season, Luis Castillo bouncing back. I guess-timated a .276/.386/.336/.722 line for Castillo and he actually hit .302/.387/.346/.732.  Hooray for me.

Equally, I wanted to put my foot in my mouth for predicting Ryan Church was going to have a re-breakout year.  Though he has played D well, his bat didn’t return to the level I thought it would.  Boo for me.

I’m sure I’m missing a bunch of other statistical anomalies and I’m curious what you guys feel are some of your best/worst predictions, so I figured we could use this thread to discuss.