Amazin' Avenue: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Pro Quality. Fan Perspective.
Around SBN: Can Tebow Say No To Anything?

Holliday vs. Bay, Defensively

Despite his ill-fated attempt to catch the ball with his crotch in this year's NLDS, Matt Holliday is superior to Jason Bay defensively.  You wouldn't evaluate a player's batting skills based on 1 plate appearance and you shouldn't judge a player's defense based on 1 misplay.  I've seen the Bay > Holliday myth propagated in a number of places so it's worth addressing.  Here are each player's UZR and +/- (in runs saved) for the last 3 seasons combined:

Player UZR +/-
Matt Holliday +29 +22
Jason Bay -43 -17

 

Additionally, Holliday rated higher than Bay according to the Fans Scouting Report this season.  The extent to which Bay sucks defensively is up for debate but it's pretty clear he is below average while Holliday is above average.  The end.

0 recs  |  Comment 35 comments |

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

No arguements here

Bay is definitely not as good of a fielder.

by KeithsMoustache on Nov 11, 2009 9:37 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

"You wouldn't evaluate a player's batting skills based on 1 plate appearance and you shouldn't judge a player's defense based on 1 misplay."

I’m with you one hundred percent!
In an unrelated note, we really need to get rid of Beltran.

"I dunno. I never smoked any Astroturf"
-Tug McGraw

by squid92 on Nov 11, 2009 10:07 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

I was thinking this exact thing

as soon as I read that. God, I hate typical fans.

"[The Giants] beat us down. We were beat by a grown-man team, a team we want to be like one day. They came in here and took it to us. Out-manned us, out-gunned us. ... It wasn't even close." - Raheem Morris, 9/27/09

by cjmulrain on Nov 12, 2009 12:11 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

speaking of the choir

Isn’t there anyone who doesn’t quite drink the Holliday punch around here? Or thinks that perhaps its best the Mets don’t “win” the winter by landing EITHER Bay OR Holliday with an unwieldy and interminable Boras-ian contract, so when Omar is fired there will be flexibility and $$ for the hopefully more competent GM that replaces him to use to maneuver us into post season glory? From what I can see, there is nothing but choir for this mile-high masher: its the Coors Choir for Holliday. Yeah he plays left field and doesn’t suck. Is a $17-20 mil a year left fielder really what this team needs now? My feeling is that the Mets really are not one player away from being competitive, and when the surgeon’s knives are all finally put down for the winter, we may be in even more dire straits than we think.

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 1:03 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

Why did you throw Bay and Holliday in together?

They’re very different players. Also, this:

Yeah he plays left field and doesn’t suck. Is a $17-20 mil a year left fielder really what this team needs now? My feeling is that the Mets really are not one player away from being competitive, and when the surgeon’s knives are all finally put down for the winter, we may be in even more dire straits than we think.

is just kind of a mish mash of catchphrases. Is a $17-20MM LF what the team needs? Well the team does need a LFer and most people would say Holliday is worth 17-20MM. Are the Mets one player away from being competitive? No, but nobody expects them to just acquire one player this winter.

by Sam Page on Nov 12, 2009 1:19 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

"Why did you throw Bay and Holliday in together?"

several posts on AA did it as well as this one, not me. I just do the mish mash of catch phrases.
Just wondering if there’s a more modest plan out there to be defended.

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 3:15 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Check the FanPosts

Any FanPost with “AAOP” in the title is an offseason plan.

by James Kannengieser on Nov 12, 2009 3:26 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

So having four players with potential of having over 5 WAR

won’t make us competitive?

"We must win and we must know how to win rather than win because we have statistical people."

by Evan_S on Nov 12, 2009 2:00 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I meant position players

Damn you for pointing out my mistakes!!! DAMN YOU!!!!

"We must win and we must know how to win rather than win because we have statistical people."

by Evan_S on Nov 12, 2009 3:02 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

and boom_roasted goes the dynamite

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 3:20 PM EST up reply actions   1 recs

Holliday, Reyes, Beltran, Wright, and Johan make 5

"We're just as bad as the old Mets, but this time nobody's laughing"
-Dallas Green

by Schmidtxc on Nov 12, 2009 12:58 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I'm a big Mike Cameron fan

I’d rather have Cameron for a year and $10-$11 million than Holliday for 6 years and $110 million. Not really sure if there’s any Holliday Kool-Aid around here to be honest.

by James Kannengieser on Nov 12, 2009 7:32 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

there seems to be a definite "consensus," if not a refreshing powdered summer beverage

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 3:17 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I think the consensus is definitely on Holliday

But I don’t think that people are getting castigated for putting forth other reasonable options. That’s why I don’t think it’s fair to go to “Kool-Aid” status quite yet. When everyone here starts foaming at the, um, AA comment at the mere mention of a LF who is not Matt Holliday playing for the Mets next year, then maybe we’ll have reached it.

"He's definitely mixing it into his repertoire. That's French for 'repertoire' " - Keith Hernandez

by Catsmeat Potter-Pirbright on Nov 12, 2009 7:19 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I think we all agree that Holliday is the best available LF

but may disagree on who is the best overall considering our needs and our resources.

by TheBigStapler on Nov 12, 2009 10:09 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

I meant to say “best overall for us

by TheBigStapler on Nov 12, 2009 10:10 AM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Yeah, I agree with you.

I don’t get the Holliday love either.

I don’t think Holliday has achieved “Kool Aid” status yet, maybe more like Lipton Iced Tea mix. Give it time though, it’s only November.

by Mex_17 on Nov 12, 2009 12:28 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Holliday Punch!

spill it on your crotch!

Francouer=Moonshine

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 3:13 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Nonsense.

It only took two weeks for this place to turn into Francoeur Avenue, yeah?

"I dunno. I never smoked any Astroturf"
-Tug McGraw

by squid92 on Nov 12, 2009 6:39 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Fan scouting

Interestingly, the fans scouting report actually said Bay was better in 2008 and 2006. I’m convinced Holliday is the better defender, but I’m not at all sure by how much. What happened to Bay the last 2-3 years that he suddenly is looking awful on UZR?

One thing that makes the comparison especially difficult is that you are dealing with two unusual ball parks, with both Coors field and the green monster in Fenway, which makes it hard to be sure the UZRs are going to be accurate measures.

My guess is the defensive difference between the two is more like -10 runs, which is about what total zone suggests if you use career data. But I don’t have a high degree of confidence in the accuracy of that.

 

by acerimusdux on Nov 12, 2009 3:29 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

what does the Green Monsta do to fielding--have we any comparative studies?

other than provide excellent rest room facilities that is. I have seen what it did to Thrilledge.

I.M. Forme
"When you get yourself into trouble is when you feel you have to do something, and then you get yourself in trouble." --Omar Minaya

by itsmetsforme on Nov 12, 2009 3:19 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

The extent to which Bay sucks defensively is up for debate but it’s pretty clear he is below average while Holliday is above average. The end.

http://www.capitolavenueclub.com/

by PWHjort on Nov 12, 2009 9:42 AM EST reply actions   0 recs

I still have a few qualms about the advanced fielding stats

but when the disparity is this huge, I don’t think there’s any way you can dispute that Bay’s a better fielder than Holliday.

"[The Giants] beat us down. We were beat by a grown-man team, a team we want to be like one day. They came in here and took it to us. Out-manned us, out-gunned us. ... It wasn't even close." - Raheem Morris, 9/27/09

by cjmulrain on Nov 12, 2009 12:13 PM EST reply actions   0 recs

right

obviously. I’m just an idiot

"[The Giants] beat us down. We were beat by a grown-man team, a team we want to be like one day. They came in here and took it to us. Out-manned us, out-gunned us. ... It wasn't even close." - Raheem Morris, 9/27/09

by cjmulrain on Nov 12, 2009 1:03 PM EST up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Start posting about the Mets »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Mr-met-r_0_small
Do the Media and Blogosphere owe Omar an apology?
159714144_040c6c1501_small
Our National Baseball Laboratory
Small
Looking At What We Have, Part 1: Position Players
Small
Looking at what we do have, Part 2: Pitchers
Headshot_small
Omar Minaya's UltiMET Lineup

Recent FanPosts

Small
I Believe in Comebacks... and Chan Ho Park?
Small
The Truth about the Mets' 2010 Budget
Small
2010 Most and Least Improved Teams
Misc_007_small
When Cliff Floyd Spoke, Players Listened
39135485-59af19dbb26654095f910f34176af094_4ae8a81e-scaled_small
Predictions Group
Buckner_small
Updating the 'Diamonds in the Rough'
Small
Debunking False Childhood Memories

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

FanShots

Quick hits of video, photos, quotes, chats, links and lists that you find around the web.

Recommended FanShots

Omar's off-season contract strategy.  (Get it?)
(Yes, I'm having too much fun with GraphJam)
I'm doing a little study on the NL East and thought I'd share an interesting little tidbit.  To all of the self-loathing Mets fans/lazy 'MLB insiders' and journalistic parrots who have 1) Condemned the entire Mets organization as a joke 2) Written off this core's impressive run to date and 3) Deified the Phillies as unstoppable juggernauts w/ no chance to lose this division:

Yes, those wins are weighted towards '06-'07 and yes, the Phillies' are more recent but the fact remains that no other team in that span can even come close to the Mets total of days in first place, which should be garnering a lot more respect than it has.  If only because we still have nearly the same core in place that has clearly had a lot of success and health-willing can very easily do so again in 2010.

Recent FanShots

Another Ken Rosenthal fail..
Mets reach agreement with Pagan
Mets close to minor league deal with Mike Jacobs
FORBES RIPS WILPON
Mets Equipment Truck Leaves for Spring Training
Mets Claim OF Jason Pridie Off Waivers From Twins
Ted Berg on the Mets offseason
Dykstra is at it again..
Phillips admits he made some mistakes

+ New FanShot All FanShots >

Sponsors


THE BIG GUY

Aa_avatar_small Eric Simon

THE INCREDIBLES

Blackfish2_small Alex Nelson

Mos_def_def2_small Sam Page

Aaavatar_small Mark Himmelstein

Best_infield_ever_small James Kannengieser

THE NEWS GURU

Wrightfront_small Joe Budd

THE POET LAUREATE

Hamheadshot__1__small Howard Megdal