Let's assume the following:
1) The Mets don't have a lot of money to spend.
2) Pelfrey will make $5m at arbitration.
3) Capuano will get -- and accept -- a two year, $14m contract ($7m each year) with a $1m buyout on a third year at $7m.
4) Alderson decides that he only wants to retain one, going with a rotation of Dickey, Niese, Gee, one of those two, and Santana/fill-in, for 2012, so that he can save money to spend elsewhere (e.g. Reyes).
Which do you retain?