Let's assume the following:
1) The Mets don't have a lot of money to spend.
2) Pelfrey will make $5m at arbitration.
3) Capuano will get -- and accept -- a two year, $14m contract ($7m each year) with a $1m buyout on a third year at $7m.
4) Alderson decides that he only wants to retain one, going with a rotation of Dickey, Niese, Gee, one of those two, and Santana/fill-in, for 2012, so that he can save money to spend elsewhere (e.g. Reyes).
Which do you retain?
Which would you prefer to have in 2012?
Mike Pelfrey (200 votes)
Chris Capuano (316 votes)
516 total votes