Congratulations to Simons, who won thanks to his Nostradamus-like guess of the total pitch count. Also, he's totally not related to me.
| AA Member | HR Derby Runner-Up | ASG Winning Team | ASG Winning Pitcher | Over/Under 2.5 HR | Jose Reyes SB | ASG MVP | Total Pitches | Score | ||
| Answer Sheet | Alex Rios | American League | Josh Beckett | Over | Yes | Ichiro! | 292 | -- | ||
| Simons | Alex Rios | National League | Jake Peavy | Over | Yes | Magglio Ordonez | 291 | 4 | ||
| The Irresistable Force | Prince Fielder | American League | Jonathon Papelbon | Over | Yes | Justin Morneau | 299 | 3 | ||
| DocMets16 | Albert Pujols | American League | C.C. Sabathia | Over | Yes | Alex Rodriguez | 300 | 3 | ||
| Mikeybags84 | Justin Morneau | American League | Francisco Rodriguez | Over | Yes | Vladimir Guerrero | 310 | 3 | ||
| Josh | Justin Morneau | American League | Dan Haren | Over | Yes | Alex Rodriguez | 272 | 3 | ||
| BlackOps | Matt Holliday | American League | Justin Verlander | Over | Yes | Vladimir Guerrero | 375 | 3 | ||
| Max in NJ | Albery Pujols | American League | Jonathon Papelbon | Over | No | Magglio Ordonez | 310 | 2 | ||
| anonymous | Vladimir Guerrero | American League | Dan Haren | Over | No | Alex Rodriguez | 333 | 2 | ||
| kingcritical | Prince Fielder | National League | Jake Peavy | Over | Yes | David Wright | 264 | 2 | ||
| Shomov | Ryan Howard | National League | Jake Peavy | Over | Yes | Barry Bonds | 320 | 2 | ||
| whynot | Prince Fielder | National League | Cole Hamels | Over | No | Chase Utley | 260 | 2 | ||
| mrmetfan15 | Albert Pujols | National League | Chris Young | Over | Yes | Carlos Beltran | 285 | 2 | ||
| TheFlushingKings | Ryan Howard | National League | Francisco Cordero | Under | No | Miguel Cabrera | 296 | 0 |