clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

2008 Mets Post-Mortem: The Cost Of Injuries

New, comments

If you want to know how a team with a $138 million payroll can miss the playoffs, take a gander at the lineup. Not that one. I mean the one in queue outside the trainer's room. Injuries are a part of the game, and some players certainly carry higher risks of injury than others. Older players and players with prior health problems are obvious candidates for a trip or two to the disabled list. Especially high-risk individuals are those injury double-threats: Aging players who have a laundry list of past ailments and afflictions (see: Alou, Moises).

Every team suffers its share of games lost to the disabled list. The Yankees had Jorge Posada, Chien-Ming Wang and Joba Chamberlain all spend time on the shelf; the Red Sox missed David Ortiz, Josh Beckett and Curt Schilling for varying lengths of time; the Braves missed Chipper Jones, Tim Hudson, John Smoltz and Tom Glavine at one point or another, so the Mets clearly aren't on an island with respect to busted goods.

I wanted to know exactly how many man-games the Mets lost due to injury this season. So, armed with their transaction ledger, salary data, schedule and my trusty spreadsheet, I had a look-see at how many games individual Mets players missed while on the disabled list. A few caveats:

  • I only counted time on the disabled list; missed games while injured but on the active roster were not counted.
  • I guesstimated slightly with respect to the day a player went on/came off the disabled list. As a rule, and to be conservative, I counted both days as days on the active roster (i.e. *not* disabled list days).
  • For the sake of simplicity, I counted pitcher missed days the same as hitter missed days. I figured it wasn't worth the added complexity of figuring out missed starts, etc., so all team games were treated equally.
  • I didn't include Tony Armas's or Trot Nixon's missed days because #$%^ 'em, that's why.

Having said that, here are the results:

Player 2008 Salary Salary/Game Missed Games Salary Missed
Moises Alou $7,500,000.00 $46,296.30 139.00 $6,435,185.19
Marlon Anderson $1,050,000.00 $6,481.48 42.00 $272,222.22
Luis Castillo $6,250,000.00 $38,580.25 65.00 $2,507,716.05
Ramon Castro $1,975,000.00 $12,191.36 32.00 $390,123.46
Ryan Church $2,000,000.00 $12,345.68 56.00 $691,358.02
Orlando Hernandez $7,000,000.00 $43,209.88 162.00 $7,000,000.00
John Maine $450,000.00 $2,777.78 34.00 $94,444.44
Pedro Martinez $11,813,351.00 $72,921.92 54.00 $3,937,783.67
Angel Pagan $401,500.00 $2,478.40 125.00 $309,799.38
Duaner Sanchez $850,000.00 $5,246.91 11.00 $57,716.05
Billy Wagner $10,500,000.00 $64,814.81 49.00 $3,175,925.93
Matt Wise $1,200,000.00 $7,407.41 147.00 $1,088,888.89
TOTAL $50,989,851.00 $26,229.35 916.00 $25,961,163.30

Nine-hundred and sixteen missed games at an average cost-per-game of $26,229.35 for a grand total of $25,961,163.30 of lost wages due to injury. That's almost $26 million, which will pay for C.C. Sabathia's 2009 salary, among other things. For poops and pickles, if the Mets had that money back their 2008 payroll would have been more like $112 million, not $138 million. To be honest, I have no idea how much the Mets team attrition compares to other clubs, but 916 games is a ton of missed time.

Keep in mind that I only included players whom the Mets could have reasonably expected to be on their 25-man roster for the whole season. Here's the positional breakdown:

  • Starting pitching: 250 games, $11,032,228.11
  • Relief pitching: 207 games, $4,322,530.86
  • Infield: 65 games, $2,507,716.05
  • Outfield: 195 games, $6,435,185.19
  • Bench: 199 games, $972,145.06

Even with all of these injuries the Mets still had a great chance to make the playoffs this season. I'd be making excuses if I blamed their having fallen short on bad health, though it'd be equally naive to suggest that their physical breakdowns didn't play any role in their ultimate demise. To have four players from your would-be active roster miss at least 125 games apiece and not have your record suffer to some degree is unrealistic. Plenty of blame still falls on Omar Minaya for not having reasonable contingency plans for some of these guys, most notably Alou and Hernandez, who were safe bets to miss significant time in any given year. Still, a little more luck in the health department and we might not be grinding our teeth bitterly as we watch other teams take their hacks at baseball history.