clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Off Day WAR: The Best And Worst Seasons By Mets Second Basemen

New, 17 comments

Continuing the wins above replacement (WAR) series, here are the best seasons by Mets second basemen per Sean Smith's WAR database:

Rank Year Player WAR
1 2000 Edgardo Alfonzo 6.5
2 1999 Edgardo Alfonzo 6.1
3 1986 Wally Backman 3.5
4 1973 Felix Millan 3.3
5 2006 Jose Valentin 3.3
6 1990 Gregg Jefferies 2.9
7 1994 Jeff Kent 2.9
8 1964 Ron Hunt 2.8
9 1995 Jeff Kent 2.8
10 1963 Ron Hunt 2.7
Tied 1966 Ron Hunt 2.7
Tied 1988 Wally Backman 2.7

 And the bottom 10:

Rank Year Player WAR
38 1962 Charlie Neal -0.3
39 1998 Carlos Baerga -0.3
40 2008 Luis Castillo -0.4
41 1977 Felix Millan -0.5
42 2005 Miguel Cairo -0.5
43 1972 Ken Boswell -0.6
44 1974 Felix Millan -0.6
45 1981 Doug Flynn -1.2
46 1978 Doug Flynn -1.7
47 1979 Doug Flynn -2.0

 Quick thoughts:

  • That's a huge dropoff between the top two Alfonzo seasons and third place.  Backman picked the right time to have a career year.
  • The biggest gap between best and worst season belongs to Felix Millan.  Amazingly, they were in back to back seasons. 
  • Contributions from the likes of Valentin made all the difference for the 2006 Mets.  Replace the 2008 trio of Castillo/Easley/A. Reyes with 2006 Valentin and the Mets likely would have made the playoffs.
  • Doug Flynn, yikes. 

For more on Mets second basemen, check out Alex Nelson's retrospective at Mets Geek: Part 1 and Part 2.  Finally, enjoy this picture of our current and future(?!) second basemen exchanging an awkward fist pound:

Castillo_and_murphy_medium