AAOP: Picture Them In Orange and Blue

The 2022 season produced 101 wins but ultimately ended with and early postseason exit. The team was a lot of fun, the players were easy to root for and the organization made strides of improvement from top to bottom.

Now we set our sights to 2023, and beyond. I’m trying in this plan to make a highly-competitive team in 2023 that can challenge for a World Series title without mortgaging future years success. Let’s try fill our beloved jerseys with the faces we all know and some faces that are new to the orange and blue.

Qualifying Offers

· Jacob deGrom

· Edwin Diaz

· Chris Bassitt

· Brandon Nimmo

All offers get rejected.


· Jacob deGrom (3/145)

I’m not going to spend much time defending this. You’ve seen him pitch, you’ve seen him excel. The Mets are in the best position to win with a generational talent at the top of the rotation. That's all there is to it.


#48 Jacob deGrom

· Edwin Diaz (5/102)

The money is easy to predict, because I am writing this from the future when Edwin Diaz has already resigned with the Mets. Do I love the contract? No, but I can live with it and it locks up the best closer in the game. So I’ll run with it.


#39 Edwin Diaz

· Adam Ottavino (2/9)

Ottavino’s walk rate for the five years prior to last seasons were all at least 4.4 BB/9. Last season his walk rate dropped to 2.2. All the while his strikeout rate stayed above 10 K/9. Why am I telling you this? You saw him. He was good! Bring him back.

Adam O

#0 Adam Ottavino


· Carlos Rodon (5/125)*

The 5/125 is only part of the cost, as Rodon is tied to the qualifying offer he received from the Giants. I would’ve preferred signing him last season, but I’ll take him when I can get him. The qualifying offer rules do hurt, but I find comfort in his pedigree (former top 10 draft pick) and recent emergence, reaching his one-time potential. I can certainly see an argument for signing Senga, but I can’t personally say I know enough about him to feel more comfortable signing him over Rodon.


#16 Carlos Rodon

· Mitch Haniger (3/27)

Mitch Haniger has mixed great production with bad injury history for his career. Is this a risk? Yes. But it also offers a strong value play. A three-year commitment at $27 million would hamstring the organization either if it doesn’t work out. He will have to get a new uniform number. 17 is off the board, pretty boy.


not #17 Mitch Haniger

· Andrew Chafin (2/14)

A solid, reliable left-handed reliever. Never too late to try something new.


#37 Andrew Chafin

· Matt Moore (1/3)

A second left-handed reliever. I just wanted to hammer that point home that having variety in the bullpen should help the bullpen. It’s a novel approach, I know.

Matt Moore

#45 Matt Moore

· Brad Boxberger (1/2.5)

Boxberger (aka Cubed Meat) would be a low-leverage veteran presence that would offer low-cost stability around the parade of arms that shuttle between Queens and Syracuse.

Cubed Meat

Also #45 Brad Boxberger


· Non-tender Dom Smith

· Release Darin Ruf

I can’t think of many people that take pleasure in non-tendering Dom Smith.

I’ll be honest, I almost kept Ruf around for his low $3M salary. I could see him getting back on track in Spring Training and having a solid season in limited action in 2023. But not as part of this vision.

40-Man Roster Addition

· Jake Mangum

As I write this section, the Mets did not protect Jake Mangum from the Rule 5 draft. I have a strong feeling that decision is going hurt. But since this is my fantasy offseason, I get to live in my own little world where the Mets roster Mangum, eventually call him up and watch his bat-to-ball skills make Jeff McNeil proud.


· Mark Vientos to Oakland for Seth Brown (OF) and Jeff Criswell (AAA Pitcher)

I’m not expecting to get much support for this. I ran this through the trade simulator and the trade favors Oakland. I know that doesn’t help my case. But hear me out.

Vientos has no fit on this roster. 3B? Escobar and Baty are both ahead of him with the bat and glove. I’d also play Luis Guillorme ahead of him. Right-handed DH? Backup 1B? I'd still put Baty in that spot or Alvarez for DH when he comes up.

So maybe I’m getting 75 cents on a dollar in the trade but that dollar isn’t being put to good use. Vientos could get regular playing time in Oakland and be more valuable to them. Meanwhile Seth Brown would be a valuable fourth outfielder now and something to have for years to come. He has experience playing all three outfield positions, and has a cromulent 112 WRC+ over 950 career plate appearances. He is also a year from arbitration. Criswell is currently a AAA starter that could be on the bullpen shuttle this season or could help strengthen a weak upper-minors pitching staff.

Seth Brown

#15 Seth Brown

A few items of note:

· Francisco Alvarez would be on the 40-man, but would start the season in AAA to work on defense. One injury to McCann or Nido and he’s up. But I don’t think it’s worthwhile to dump McCann or Nido and then find out Alvarez’s defense is ready for the big league level.

· Tylor Megill struggled coming out of the bullpen last season. He went to the bullpen after coming off the injury list and I’d be hopeful that he could do well if that was a role he assumed from the start of spring training. I could see him in a similar role as to what Trevor Williams provided last season where he would pitch multiple innings from the pen or make abbreviated starts when needed. I can also imagine him working into a six-man rotation late in the season to give some added rest to the elder starters that will help carry the team in the postseason.

· The final 3 spots on the 40 man roster would be saved for Rule 5 draft pickups. My ideal scenario here would be to find one stash and hold long-term player with high upside and two Rule 5 picks that could offer bullpen help, shuttling from Syracuse to Queens.

Player Roster Pos 2023 2024 2025 2026 2027
1 Pete Alonso 26 1B $15,900,000
2 Jeff McNeil 26 2B $6,200,000
3 Eduardo Escobar 26 3B $9,500,000 $9,000,000
4 Tomas Nido 26 C $1,600,000
5 Daniel Vogelbach 26 DH $1,500,000
6 Mark Canha 26 OF $10,500,000 $11,500,000
7 Mitch Haniger 26 OF $9,000,000 $9,000,000 $9,000,000
8 Starling Marte 26 OF $20,750,000 $20,750,000 $20,750,000
9 Francisco Lindor 26 SS $34,100,000 $34,100,000 $34,100,000 $34,100,000 $34,100,000 $34.1M annually til 2031
10 Brett Baty 26 3B $650,000
11 James McCann 26 C $12,150,000 $12,150,000
12 Seth Brown 26 OF $650,000
13 Luis Guillorme 26 SS $1,500,000
14 Adam Ottavino 26 RP $4,500,000 $4,500,000
15 Andrew Chafin 26 RP $7,000,000 $7,000,000
16 Brad Boxberger 26 RP $2,500,000
17 Drew Smith 26 RP $1,200,000
18 Edwin Diaz 26 RP $20,400,000 $20,400,000 $20,400,000 $20,400,000 $20,400,000
19 Matt Moore 26 RP $3,000,000
20 Steven Nogosek 26 RP $650,000
21 Tylor Megill 26 RP $650,000
22 Max Scherzer 26 SP $43,333,333 $43,333,334
23 Carlos Carrasco 26 SP $14,000,000
24 Jacob deGrom 26 SP $45,000,000 $45,000,000 $45,000,000
25 Carlos Rodon 26 SP $25,000,000 $25,000,000 $25,000,000 $25,000,000 $25,000,000
26 David Peterson 26 SP $650,000
27 Francisco Alvarez 40 C $650,000
28 Jake Mangum 40 OF $650,000
29 Khalil Lee 40 OF $650,000
30 Ronny Mauricio 40 SS $650,000
31 Bryce Montes deOca 40 RP $650,000
32 Jeff Criswell 40 RP $650,000
33 John Curtiss 40 RP $775,900
34 Sean Reid-Foley 40 RP $650,000
35 Yoan Lopez 40 RP $650,000
36 Joey Lucchesi 40 SP $1,150,000
37 Jose Butto 40 SP $650,000
38 Rule 5 spot (tbd) P $650,000
39 Rule 5 spot (tbd) P $650,000
40 Rule 5 spot (tbd) tbd $650,000
DEAD MONEY Cano + Ruf $23,250,000
TOTAL $324,859,233 $241,733,334 $154,250,000 $79,500,000 $79,500,000
BUDGET $325,000,000
remaining funds $140,767

This FanPost was contributed by a member of the community and was not subject to any vetting or approval process.